Fan Theories - The X-Files, The Tommy Westphall Universe, Lost and more

Major spoilers for The X-Files, St. Elsewhere, Lost, The Shining

As I watched The X-Files the other day I noticed something slightly peculiar. The episode was Chinga, which is about an evil cursed doll, but what was peculiar was the actor playing the sheriff had appeared in The X-Files before, in Jose Chung's 'From Outer Space', where he played a detective. I have looked it up and he has been in the show five times playing different characters. This happens quite often in television, especially American shows where they might have twenty episodes a season, But it perhaps offers an interesting additional insight. In the world of the show are they meant to be completely separate characters? The X-Files has had episodes about clones and about creatures that change their appearance, is there more going on here? The short answer is no, I'm sure the producers just knew he was a good actor so why not keep using him? There a lot of fan theories in television and movies, sometimes involving just the world of the show, sometimes more about how it was made.

Larry Musser - this guy played five different characters in The X-Files

The best fan theory has to be the "Tommy Westphall Universe" theory from the tv show St. Elsewhere. It's not a show I've ever watched but at the end of the show it became apparent that the entire universe of St. Elsewhere existed only in the imagination of one of the characters; Tommy Westphall. That isn't the weird part, the weird part is that some characters from St. Elsewhere have appeared in other television shows, which would suggest they only exist in Tommy's imagination as well, such as Homicide: Life On The Streets. Currently The Tommy Westphall Universe blog has listed 419 tv shows as potentially only existing in Tommy's mind. Really though it can effectively cover all of film and television as any actor appearing on St Elsewhere was just a creation of Tommy, so it could follow that Denzel Washington is his creation, and all of the films Washington has made are his creation and that all the actors in all those different films are Tommy's creations and on and on.....
To see the complete list of shows and more ideas about the theory go to https://thetommywestphall.wordpress.com/the-master-list/

Tommy Westphall - who imagined hundreds of tv shows

There are three main fan theory categories that have been suggested for so many things they've become a little cliched:

1. It's just someone's fantasy - examples -Harry Potter, Titanic, Saved By The Bell, Ferris Bueller's Day Off, Friends - all these and more have been suggested as the fantasy of one of the central characters or a large part is fantasy. Something like Harry Potter, where a person is whisked away from a dull or bad life into something new and exciting and where they are very special is a common psychological problem in people who have had traumatic lives. Ferris Bueller's Day Off is said to be largely the creation of Ferris's friend, Cameron, the neurotic stressed out, weirdo who created the figure of Ferris Bueller to allow him to do stuff he really wanted to do.

Ferris Bueller...this guy was a fantasy

2. They're dead - Fresh Prince of Bel Air, Rug Rats, Grease, Mad Men, Interstellar, Breaking Bad - this is perhaps the most common, a central character has died and the story taking place is either the dying dream of the person or their perception of the afterlife. In The Fresh Prince of Bel Air Will was actually killed in the fight shown in the opening credits and living in rich Bel Air was Heaven. Just looking up these theories I found the one about Rug Rats, in that all the children apart from Angelica, are dead most disturbing.

Will Smith...this guy was dead

For category 1 and 2 it should be a distinction made between films where this is a fan theory and what is actually supposed to have happened in the story, so far example Grease is a film where there is a theory that Sandy has been dead all along, but  in The Sixth Sense Bruce Willis's psychiatrist actually has been dead all along.

3. Everything is connected - Tarantino, Pixar universe- these are theories about connected pieces of work and how they share a deeper connection, for example with the works of Quentin Tarantino. It started with the idea that Kill Bill starring Uma Thurman as a member of a team of assassins is very similar to the tv show described by Uma Thurman's character, Mia Wallace, in Pulp Fiction, is Kill Bill simply the film of the fictional tv show from Pulp Fiction? It has since been expanded with Inglourious Basterds into something far more complicated, in this film Hitler is gunned down, set on fire and blown up, which is obviously different to reality and a theory suggests that in an alternate universe that is what happened. In this alternate universe as these acts of violence brought an end to World War 2 pop culture is far more violent and aggressive so films like Kill Bill or Django Unchained are made. So there are two types of Tarantino films - first the ones like Inglourious Basterds which are the audience seeing this alternate reality, and second type like Kill Bill which are movies from that alternate universe. Tarantino has recently confirmed that this theory is right insofar as Kill Bill is the film version of the tv show mentioned in Pulp Fiction.

The interconnected Tarantino films

The Shining is a film with so many bizarre theories they made a film about some of them, Room 237. What is the film really about? One of the most interesting theories is that it is Kubrick's confession that he faked the moon landing footage and while I don't believe this for one second there is a somewhat convincing argument.  The proponent of this theory goes to some lengths to show how everything in a Kubrick film is put there intentionally - another documentary Stanley Kubrick's Boxes showed the huge lengths Kubrick went to to get things exactly right - so why is Danny wearing a jumper with the Apollo 11 rocket on it? That was Kubrick's subtle clue that he had filmed the moon landing. Other theories include the film is all about the genocide of Native Americans, or that it's about the holocaust. Many peculiar little features are pointed out, the layout of the hotel doesn't seem to make sense and why does the typewriter Jack used change colour? And if you think that these odd little mistakes are just some oversight on Kubrick's part then you don't know Kubrick. As mentioned if something was in shot it was there for a reason, if that typewriter changed colour it's because it meant something to Kubrick.

The Shining - Kubrick's elaborate confession that he faked the moon landing

In terms of fan theories Lost is very much The Shining of the television world (but is certainly not it's equal in quality or originality). I gave up on Lost as I felt like the writers had no idea where it was going and that their plots were picked the same way South Park claimed jokes were written for Family Guy. Every week something new and weird popped up and there came a point where I realised the writers were never going to be able to satisfactorily explain it all. In fact, fans of the show had guessed the plot-twist, that they had been dead all along and the island was some weird purgatory, quite early on but this was denied by the writers. Lost is the perfect show for fans to make up their own theories as the show was so overly complicated and had all kinds of weird stuff going on and even when the "real" explanation was given fans have kept coming up with their own "better" theories.

Lost - there are far too many theories for this show

Here are a few of the suggested theories:

• The island is Hell, 
• The island is Eden (as in Adam and Eve Eden), 
• The island is Atlantis.
• The island is a broken time machine from the future.
• The island is an alien spaceship
• The island was created when the moon and Earth collided,
• The island is a "Truman Show" style reality tv show/board game played by powerful people/social experiment
• The black smoke monster is a cloud of nanobots 
• The whole thing is caused by the Y2K virus
• Clones!
• Dinosaurs!
• Zombies!

Increasingly some of these theories don't have much evidence behind them other than just being weird. The actual finale to the show was considered to be a disappointment by many as it failed to tie everything together in a pleasing way. I think to do that you need to know from the beginning what is going to happen and where the show is going and I can't help but think they just made it up as they went along. The reimagined Battlestar Galactica struck me as a show where the writers had planned everything out in advance and broadly knew what was going to happen every season but Lost just seemed to have the weirdness turned up to 11. In many ways Lost is similar to The X-Files in that The X-Files showed lots and lots of weird things happen and for all of it to make some kind of logical sense was impossible.

So we're back to The X-Files which is back on television and I am watching very closely to see if this guy turns up again.